I’d been contemplating going short again (I’d taken the plunge once before, in seventh grade) for a while before I actually went through with it about a month ago. I’d spent many an hour online googling “short hair” and “pixie cut” looking for inspiration, for something to convince me one way or the other. Because the truth is that bleaching my hair really wrecked it, and I was desperately looking for an excuse to get rid of my gnarled tresses. It was at about this point that I came across this provocative article by former Elle contributor Johanna Cox, on the effect of short hair on one’s love life. I’d read that Alexa Chung felt un-sexy with her hair bobbed, and I’d heard other horror stories of girls with pixie cuts feeling boyish and unattractive, but to hear Johanna relate the story of her boyfriend revealing he was no longer attracted to her with short hair was downright frightening:
That boyfriend and I ultimately parted romantic ways, but we remain good friends. After all, it was his brutal honesty that prepared me for the next two years, when I would experience what it feels like to be consistently passed over by a majority of men simply because they, like him, believed they could never be attracted to a woman with supershort hair. … A self-righteous attitude, as opposed to my body language or sense of style, was now the first impression I made on most men. As a result—and it was immediate—the nice guy, the skeevy married man, even the construction worker left me alone.
I personally can’t help but read that and think, well then, f*** ‘em! But it’s still scary to think that committing to something like this, something I couldn’t reverse and would have to live with for a year, minimum, could cause me to turn into a single, social pariah. At the same time, I understand where Johanna’s boyfriend was coming from, because dating a girl with short hair could, to the mans’ ego, seeming call his sexuality into question. But why does hair length have to be identified with sexual orientation? Or gender? I was under the impression that this was the twenty-first century.
Which brings me to the bit about how I hate the idiotic but somehow all-pervasive notion that all girls with short hair are lesbians. Joking or not, guys love to ask of my drastic change from super long blonde to platinum pixie, “Does this mean you’re gay?” At which point I retaliate by punching them in the balls and laughing while they write in pain. Not actually, but kind of. But then the logical line that should be inserted at this point in my narrative is “not that there’s anything wrong with being gay,” just so you all know I’m not some obnoxious bigot. And obviously there isn’t—like, DO YOU, you know—but that’s not really the point, is it? The point is that you’re judging me and my sexuality based on something as superficial as the length of my hair. No one much seems to care, for example, that they personally know my ex-boyfriend or that I consistently comment on how attractive I think the male RA down the hall is. It’s like a switch gets flipped in some people’s brains and they forget everything else and automatically assume, “OH EM GEE SHE HAS SHORT HAIR SHE MUST LIKE BOOBS.” Don’t be stupid. Like, really? Really now.
But the sad truth is that people are going think what they want to think. Someone once told me, “Ultimately, you can’t change other people. You can only change yourself.” So here I am, trying to change my self-perception, and my perception of other people’s perceptions of me… Should I just grow a tougher skin? Learn to let it all just roll off my back? Or am I in the wrong here? Is there actually a reason why girls get so much flak for having short hair? Will my lack of hair really ruin my life? WILL I BECOME A FRIENDLESS HERMIT??
I found the answer to this question the first weekend back after break—about three weeks ago now—when I went out with my friends to a party at an off-campus frat house. By the time I got there, the alcohol was pretty much gone, and everyone was already pretty well toasted, which is relevant because drunk people speak their minds. Drunk people are easy to understand, and their motives are always clear because they are no long capable of subtlety. (I like drunk people. They make sense to me.) Myself being sober, this was the perfect scenario to test out the powers of my new haircut. All of those lurking questions flared up again in my mind: Would guys still hit on me? Would anyone mention my short hair?
In fact, I have never felt more attractive. There was no shortage of attention paid to me and my friends. Multiple people I’d never met before told me they liked my hair. I could almost feel the power I was wielding, the kind of power every girl dreams of having, of being able to captivate a man’s attention, of lighting up a room. I felt it. I’m not saying I felt it because of my haircut, but I’m also not saying I felt it in spite of my haircut. No, that was all me, and the haircut had nothing to do with it.
My biggest fear in chopping off all my hair, conceited and immature as it is, was that no boy would even look at me ever again. I think I can safely say that fear has yet to be realized. Like Johanna, I have noticed a change in the way that some boys react to me; my lovable but ignorant-as-dirt guy friends make dumb comments about my sexuality or my sometimes “androgynous” look, and I’m sure some guys will pass me over because of my hair (or lack thereof). But honestly, this is where I get to say f*** ‘em and have no qualms about it. For one thing, I love androgyny! I think it’s one of the chic-est and most fashionable of modern aesthetics. And furthermore, if anyone is going to judge me because of my hair—and this goes for everyone, both guys and girls—then that person isn’t worth my time.
Johanna notes that it the set of men who showed interest in her after her haircut changed drastically, but certainly not for the worse. As I interpret it, the quantity of men that hit on her may have decreased, but the quality actually went up, producing more confident, a la mode-savvy males who appreciated both the personal style and guts behind such a haircut. I’m not sure I can really confirm this increase in “male quality” with my own experiences, but I can say that there is more to life than being chatted up at a party by some cute dude. And those things don’t definitely don’t change with the length of your hair.
A reader of this blog sent me an email a few weeks ago saying:
“I have been toying with chopping my hair like you did for a while..but am so scared Ill regret it the second I do it :/ Any regrets?”
In answer to her question, I said:
“I have no regrets. There are certainly moments of weakness when I wish I still had the boring normality of my long hair to hide behind, but there will always be times when I feel insecure, even if I hadn't cut my hair. So in the end, it was a risk I wanted to take and I took it, and I'm glad I did, because I like the results. The worst that could happen is that you won't like it, but it's not like you won't rock it anyways, and it'll definitely grow back.”
So what’s the verdict? Well, I want to go shorter. How about you?